Wasan zagaye na 16 tsakanin England da Mexico a FIFA Kofin Duniya ya zama ɗaya daga cikin mafi kawo cece-kuce da muhawara a gasar, inda yankin da aka ba da shi a kan Harry Kane ya raba ra'ayin masu sharhi na BBC sosai.

Yanke shawara uku manya, muhawara guda mai zafi

England na kan gaba da 2-1 lokacin da aka kori Jarrel Quansah bayan binciken VAR ya tabbatar da cewa sliding challenge dinsa mai tsawo a kan Jesus Gallardo ya kasance wasa mai hadari. Sai 'yan wasan England goma suka ƙara nesa lokacin da Kane ya canza burin daga wurin fanareti bayan mai tsaron ragar Mexico Raul Rangel ya faɗa da Anthony Gordon a cikin akwatin fanareti.

Duk da haka, wasan ya sake juyuwa lokacin da alkalin wasa ya duba fuska ta VAR a gefen filin kuma ya ba Mexico fanareti saboda ƙalubalen da Kane ya yi. Raul Jimenez ya taka fanareti ɗin cikin nasara, yana rage raso zuwa 3-2.

Shearer bai gamsu da yanke shawarar ba

Alan Shearer bai gamsu cewa yanke shawarar yana da kyau ba. "Shin wannan kuskure ne bayyananne da alkalin wasa ya yi?" ya tambaya bayan ya sake kallo. Shearer ya lura cewa wannan ɗan alkalin ne da ya ƙi ba da fanareti ga Kylian Mbappe a wasan France da Senegal, kuma ya ci gaba da cewa ƙalubalen Kane a kan ɗan wasan Mexico bai cancanci fanareti ba.

Cann da Hart sun goyi bayan alkalin wasa

Masanin alkalanci na BBC Darren Cann yana da ra'ayi sabanin haka. "Harry Kane, abin takaici, ya taka ƙafar ɗan Mexico," in ji Cann. "Yana kama da bugun Modric da England ta sami fanareti a kansa a wasan farko na ƙungiya, inda Harry Kane bai san ɗan wasan yana shigowa ba. Abin takaici, ya yi taɓawa. Laifi ne. Yana cikin akwatin fanareti, shi ne fanareti."

Cann ya kuma nuna cewa wannan alkalin shi ne kawai a gasar da ya duba hotunan sannan ya tsaya a yanke shawarar da ya yi tun farko — a batun fanareti da aka yi ikirarin Mbappe ya cancanta a wasan France da Senegal — amma ya ce a wannan karon, yanke shawara na ba da fanareti shi ne daidai.

Tsohon mai tsaron ragar England Joe Hart ya goyi bayan Cann da ƙarfi. "A yanke shawara ukun, na yi tunanin alkalin ya zo yanke shawara daidai," in ji Hart. "Nan da nan da na sake kallo, zukata ta yi ƙaura. Na yi tunanin Quansah ya cancanci a kore shi, na yi tunanin Kane bai taba ball ba, kuma na yi tunanin Gordon ya isa farko."

Hart ya amince da tabbacin Shearer amma ya ci gaba da cewa, a ra'ayinsa, yanke shawara ɗaya bayan ɗaya a wannan gudu na wasa an gudanar da shi daidai ta masu kula da wasan.