Pro Ref ta yarda cewa burin nasara da Erling Haaland ya ci wa Manchester City a kan Manchester United — wanda ya kare nasara ta 1-0 a Old Trafford ranar Lahadi — bai kamata ya tsaya ba, tana kiran yanke shawara na VAR a matsayin "kuskure na hukunci."

An fara hana burin Haaland na bayan gungumen a minti na 60 saboda offside a filin, kafin VAR ta soke yanke shawarar bayan ta tantance cewa mai kare Manchester United Patrick Dorgu ya sa dan wasan Norway ya kasance a matsayin daidai.

Offside da VAR ta rasa

Abin da binciken ya kasa lissafawa shi ne matsayin dan tsakiyar Manchester City Enzo Fernandez, wanda yake a matsayin offside kuma ya bayyana yana hamayya da kwallon kafin ta kai Haaland. Ko da yake Fernandez bai taba kwallon ba, motsinsa ya shafi karfin mai kare Manchester United Lisandro Martinez wajen bin guduwar Haaland da fito.

Bisa ka'idojin wasa, ana iya hukunta dan wasa saboda offside ba tare da ya taba kwallon ba idan motsinsa ya fito karara yana tsangwama wa ikon abokin hamayya na kare. Pro Ref ta yarda cewa jami'an VAR ba su la'akari da hakan ba kuma ya kamata sun nemi sake duba a filin.

A cikin sanarwa, mai magana don Pro Ref ya ce: "A cikin hari guda daya, an tabbatar da cewa Enzo Fernandez bai taka kwallon ba kuma saboda haka hakan ya mai da kowane laifin offside abu na ra'ayi, duk da haka, a wannan yanayin, VAR ta kasa gane tasirin da ake sa ran matsayinsa zai yi kuma ya kamata ta ba da shawarar sake duba a filin. An sadar da Manchester United a wannan dare don gane abin da muke ganin kuskure ne na hukunci. Za a gudanar da bitar lamarin."

Masu sharhi sun yi zargi gaba daya

Tsohon mai kare Manchester City Micah Richards ya kasance bayyananne a soki yanke shawarar. Da aka tambaye shi ko Fernandez yana kokarin wasa da kwallon fito karara, Richards ya gaya wa Sky Sports: "Kashi dari a sari yana haka. Ina ganin ya kasance rana mai muni ga alƙalai da VAR. Sun yi kuskure a yanke shawara na Phil Foden, kuma sun yi kuskure a wannan yanke shawara. Yadda za ku iya cewa Enzo Fernandez ba ya hamayya da kwallon — tabbas yana!"

Richards ya kara da cewa ko mafi karancin motsi na dan wasan gaba a wannan matsayi ya isa ya shafi karantawar mai kare na yanayin, yana mai jaddada cewa jami'an "sun yi babban kuskure."

Roy Keane ya kasance mai tsauri daidai gwargwado, yana mai jayayya cewa Manchester United sun hukuntwa don kare da kyau. "Fernandez yana tsangwama da wasan," in ji Keane. "A asashe, an hukunta United don kiyaye layi mai kyau. Layinsu yana da kyau. Fernandez yana offside, kuma ya je ya taka kwallon, don haka ana hukunta United saboda kyakkyawan kare."

Abin da Premier League Match Centre ta ce

Premier League Match Centre ta fara kare ba da burin a wata sakon a X, tana cewa VAR ta sami Haaland a matsayin daidai kuma Fernandez bai taka kwallon ba. Wannan bayani ya jawo sukar nan take, tun da ka'idojin offside ba sa bukata dan wasa ya taba kwallon domin a hukunta shi saboda tsangwama wa ikon abokin hamayya na kare.

Yarda ta Pro Ref cewa za a gudanar da bita ba ta yiwuwa ta ba Manchester United magani game da sakamakon, amma tana wakiltar wani fitaccen yarda na jama'a cewa jami'an sun yi babban kuskure a wasan Premier League.