Hukumar Kula da Manyan Abubuwan da Suka Faru a Wasanni (KMI Panel) ta Premier League ta tabbatar da kuskure shida na alkalai a filin wasa a zagayen wasanni na baya-bayan nan — inda ta daidaita mafi girman adadin da hukumar ta taba yin rikodin a karshen mako guda.
Don samun wani lokaci da kuskure shida suka faru a zagaye guda, dole ne a koma baya zuwa farkon kakar 2023-24. Jimlar ba ta hada da ingantattun tsoma bakin VAR da suka gyara kuskure ba, kamar jan katin da aka nuna wa Igor Thiago na Brentford.
Yadda hukumar ke aiki
Kowace mako, mambobi biyar masu cin gashin kansu na hukumar suna duba dukkan abubuwan da suka jawo muhawara. Suna kada kuri'a daban-daban akan tambayoyi biyu: shin alkalin filin ya yanke hukunci mai kyau bisa ka'idojin wasa? Kuma shin VAR ya yi daidai wajen tsoma baki ko kau da kai? Sakamakon yana ciyar da tebur na darajar da ke ba da gudummawa ga kashi 50 cikin 100 na albashin lada na alkalai.
Abubuwa biyu da aka kuskure a filin da kuma ta VAR
Hukumar ta gano cewa biyu ne kawai daga cikin kuskure shida da kuma suka zama tsoma bakin VAR da aka rasa — adadi wanda zai iya mamakin magoya baya da yawa.
Everton da Coventry City — Mai tsaron gida na Everton James Tarkowski ya bayyana ya kama gashi Caleb Yirenkyi na Coventry a cikin yankin hukunci, amma ba a ba da bugun fanariti ba. Hukumar ta kada kuri'a 5-0 cewa alkalin filin da VAR dukkansu sun yi kuskure. Hukumar ta ce Tarkowski yana riƙe da gashi na Yirenkyi kuma dukkan mambobin sun yarda cewa VAR ya kamata ya tsoma baki.
Arsenal da Hull City — Kai Havertz ya kamo a cikin yankin ta Nobel Mendy na Hull City. Alkalin VAR Michael Oliver ya aika da alkali Farai Hallam zuwa kallo a gefen filin, amma ba a ba da bugun fanariti ba saboda tuhumar kan wuce layi na Havertz. Hukumar ta kada kuri'a 5-0 ba daidai ba, tana cewa akwai riƙe bayyananne da mai tasiri daga Mendy kafin wani cin zarafi na wuce layi da zai yiwu.
Abubuwa hudu: kuskuren alkalai ba na VAR ba
A wasu lokuta hudu, yawancin mambobin hukumar sun yanke hukunci cewa shawarar filin ba ta dace ba, amma VAR ba shi da wajibin tsoma baki saboda dokar da ake bukata.
Everton da Coventry City (kwal) — Kwal din Thierno Barry wa Everton a minti na 61 ya sha duba ta VAR saboda hannun da zai yiwu. Hukumar ta kada kuri'a 2-3 ba daidai a filin ba, amma 5-0 a kan tsoma bakin VAR, tunda babu tabbataccen shaida daga hotunan da ake da su.
Liverpool da Crystal Palace — An ba Crystal Palace bugun fanariti a minti na 93 saboda laifin Milos Kerkez a kan Dario Osorio. Hukumar ta kada kuri'a 0-5 cewa shawarar filin ba ta dace ba, amma 5-0 a kan tsoma bakin VAR saboda kuskuren bai bayyana ko kuma a fili ba.
Bournemouth da Ipswich — An ba Ipswich bugun fanariti a minti na 72 saboda laifin Lewis Cook a kan Abdoul Ouattara. Hukumar ta kada kuri'a 1-4 cewa shawarar filin ba ta dace ba, amma 4-1 a kan tsoma bakin VAR.
Bournemouth — Rawanin katin rawaya na biyu mai yiwuwa — Marcus Tavernier na Bournemouth ya kusa samun katin rawaya na biyu saboda jinkirta ci gaban wasa. Hukumar ta kada kuri'a 2-3 ba daidai a filin ba; VAR ba zai iya tsoma baki a wannan yanayin ba.
Shawarwari masu cece-kuce da aka yanke hukunci cewa daidai ne
Wasu manyan abubuwan da suka jawo cece-kuce ba a lasafta su a matsayin kuskure ba.
An ɗauki ƙalubalantar Jayden Bogle na Leeds United a kan Mathys Tel na Tottenham a matsayin daidai da kuri'a 3-2, inda hukumar ta ce hulɗar ba ta da saurin da ake bukata, ƙarfi, ko tsanani don a kiranta wasa mai haɗari na gaske.
An kuma ɗauki tsoma bakin Luke O'Nien na Sunderland a kan Cole Palmer na Chelsea a gefen yankin a matsayin daidai da kuri'a 4-1, tare da nuni cewa fifon kyauta a wajen yankin shine da'awar da ta dace.
A daya bangaren, bugun fanariti da aka ba Sunderland bayan Levi Colwill ya tattake Brian Bobbey ya sami amincewar hukumar baki daya, kamar yadda aka yarda da daidaituwar Patrick Dorgu a minti na 96 ga Nottingham Forest a kan Aston Villa.
Me wannan ke gaya mana game da VAR?
Kuskure shida na alkalai a karshen mako guda — tare da jan katin Thiago — adadi bayyananne ne mai yawa. Duk da haka, KMI Panel ba ta neman nuna ra'ayin magoya baya; ta dogara kan ka'idojin wasa da ma'aunin alkalanci na Premier League. Wannan bambanci tsakanin kuskuren filin da tilas tsoma bakin VAR yana ci gaba da kara takaicin magoya baya.


