Wani batu mai kawo takaddama a wasan da ya hada Morgan Rogers na Aston Villa da Conor Gallagher na Atletico Madrid ya raba ra'ayoyin masu sharhi, inda muhawara ta ci gaba kan ko Rogers ya kamata a ba shi jan kati saboda harbin da ya yi wa Gallagher.

Tsohon dan wasan kai hari a Premier League Jay Bothroyd, tsohon dan wasan tsakiya na Tottenham Hotspur da Aston Villa Tim Sherwood, da kwararre kan alkalanci Dermot Gallagher duk sun bayar da ra'ayoyinsu kan lamarin — ba tare da sun yarda ba.

Hujjojin da ke nuna ya kamata a ba da jan kati

Ainihin muhawara ita ce ko aikin Rogers ya cancanci a kiransa tsananin ɗabi'a. Waɗanda ke tallafawa kori sun nuna cewa harbin da aka yi da gangan ne, suna cewa rashin aikin alkalin wasa ya kasance kuskure mai bayyana. Bisa ga dokokin wasan, tsananin ɗabi'a — wanda aka bayyana a matsayin tuntuɓar jiki mai tsanani ba tare da ƙoƙarin taka ƙwallon ba — yana kawo jan kati kai tsaye.

Ƙungiyar da ta rarrabu

Bothroyd yana cikin waɗanda suka ji cewa lamarin ya cancanci mafi girman hukunci.

"Hakan ta'adi ce mai tsanani,"

Duk da haka, sauran masu sharhi a cikin ƙungiyar sun yi jayayya cewa yanayi da niyya abu ne mai wahalar yanke hukunci a lokacin wasa, kuma yanke shawaran alkalin wasa na barin wasan ya ci gaba ya kasance, aƙalla, mai fahimta idan aka yi la'akari da saurin da lamarin ya faru.

Dermot Gallagher, yana dogara da kwarewansa mai tsawo a matsayin alkalin wasa a babban matakin gasar, ya ba da kimantawarsa ta yadda alkalin wasa ke sarrafa irin wannan yanayi a lokacin wasan — inda yanke shawarar da ake yi cikin ɗan gajeren lokaci ke ƙarƙashin nazari mai tsawo ta hanyar sake duba a hankali.

Abin da hakan ke nufi a filin wasa

Muhawara ta nuna ƙalubalen da ke maimaituwa a ƙwallon ƙafa na zamani: iyaka tsakanin ɓarna ta gasa da ɗabi'ar da ta wuce layin ladabi. Da VAR a cikin wasanni masu yawa, irin waɗannan lamura suna ƙara yin bitar — ko da yake matakan shiga tsakani a cikin kiran tsananin ɗabi'a sun kasance batun jayayya tsakanin jami'ai, horarwa, da magoya baya.

Rogers da Gallagher duka mutane ne masu muhimmanci a ƙwallon ƙafa na Turai, kuma duk wata jan kati a irin wannan wasan da ta kasance da tasirin gaske ga ƙungiyoyinsu.