Burin da Erling Haaland ya ci a wasan derby na Manchester ranar Lahadi ya bar tambayoyi da yawa ba tare da an amsa su ba — har bayan hukumar hukunci Pro Ref ta yarda da "kuskure na hukunci" wajen yarda da burin.

Manchester City ta doke Manchester United 1-0 a Old Trafford, amma burin da ya yanke hukunci yana ci gaba da cike da jayayya bayan VAR ta soke hukuncin offside da aka yanke a filin wasa domin ba da burin.

Abin da Pro Ref ya faɗa — da abin da bai faɗa ba

Pro Ref — Professional Game Referees, wanda aka fi sani da PGMOL — ya tabbatar da daren Lahadi cewa an yi kuskure. Sanarwarsu ta yarda cewa Enzo Fernandez yana cikin matsayin offside lokacin da ya yi ƙoƙarin taka ƙwallon kafin ta kai Haaland, kuma ya kamata a ci gaba da soke burin.

Sanarwar ta ce: "A wannan lokacin, VAR bai gane tasirin da aka yi tsammani na matsayinsa ba." Amma bai bayyana dalilin da ya sa VAR ya kasa yanke hukunci cewa ɗan wasa da ke nisan dakika shida daga ƙofar, yana yin header na nutsewa, ba a yi la'akari da cewa ya shafi — ko mai yiwuwa ya shafi — wasan ba.

Shin VAR ta mayar da hankali kan tambayar da ba ta dace ba?

Bayani mafi ma'ana shi ne cewa VAR ya riga ya dora hankali kan ko Fernandez ya taɓa ƙwallon — tambaya wadda, ƙarƙashin dokokin wasan, ba ta da amfani. Ɗan wasa na iya zama a matsayin offside ko ya taɓa ƙwallon ko ba ya taɓa ta.

Match Centre ya wallafa a X yayin wasan: "VAR kuma ya yanke hukunci cewa ko da yake yana cikin matsayin offside, Fernandez bai taka ƙwallon ba." Sake nuna hotunan watsa shirye-shiryen Sky Sports sun nuna ƙungiyar VAR tana binciken wannan tambayar musamman a lokacin bitar.

Dalilin da ya sa ya kamata a yi bitar filin wasa

A cewar Pro Ref, an ɗaga tutar offside ta farko a filin wasa a kan Haaland — wanda, a gaskiya, yana cikin matsayin daidai. Sannan VAR ya gano daidai cewa Fernandez yana cikin matsayin offside. Duk da haka, tun da hukuncin filin wasa ya ambaci ɗan wasa mara daidai, VAR ba zai iya tabbatar da cewa ya kamata a soke burin saboda wani dalilin daban ba.

Tsarin da ya dace, kamar yadda Pro Ref ya bayyana, shi ne VAR Matt Donohue ya nemi alkalin wasa Michael Oliver ya yi bitar filin wasa. Oliver da za a tambaye shi ya yanke hukunci na mutum ɗaya kan ko matsayin Fernandez ya shafi wasan. Wannan matakin ba a dauka ba.

Kiper ma ya samu tasiri

Sake nuna hotuna sun kuma nuna cewa kiper na Manchester United, Lammens, ya yi amsa ga ƙoƙarin header na Fernandez, yana ɗaga hannuwansa yana tsammani kuma ya rasa daidaituwa — daidai lokacin da Haaland ya buga ƙwallon. Duk da haka, matsayin Pro Ref shi ne ya kamata a soke burin ba tare da la'akari da wani tasiri a kan Lammens ba, domin Fernandez ya riga ya shafi ɗan wasa na filin wasa na Manchester United, wanda aka ambata a cikin sanarwar a matsayin Martinez.

Sauran tambayoyin da suka rage a buɗe

An ci burin Haaland a minti 59' 24". Wasan bai sake farawa ba har zuwa 63' 15" — jinkiri kusan mintoci huɗu — duk da haka an kara mintoci biyar ne kawai a ƙarshen rabi, wanda ya haifar da ƙarin tambayoyi game da ko alkalai sun lissafta doguwar bitar VAR lokacin da suka saita ƙarin lokaci.

A halin da ake ciki, fasahar offside ta semi-automated ta Premier League, wadda aka gabatar a wannan kakar, tana ba da zane mai nuna wurin bugawa maimakon layukan da aka zana da hannu waɗanda masu kallo suka saba da su — canji wanda ya hana mutane da yawa bin bitar a lokacin ainihi.