Har zuwa karshen mako da ya wuce, ƙididdiga sun ba da labari mai ta'aziyya. Kwamitin Muhimman Abubuwan Wasa (KMI Panel) — wanda ke duba kowace yanke-shawara mai cece-ku a Premier League kuma ke jefa ƙuri'a kan ingancinta — ya rubuta kurakurai biyu kawai na VAR cikin zagaye takwas na farko na kakar wasa. A matakin ɗaya a kakar da ta gabata, kurakurai shida sun riga an rubuta su.

Sa'annan sai Asabar da Lahadi su wadanda suka gwada tsarin kamar yadda 'yan karshen mako kaɗan suka yi kwanan nan, inda kusan kowace wasa a ɓangaren manyan ƙungiyoyi ta samar da aƙalla yanke-shawara ɗaya mai cece-ku. BBC Sport ta tantance muhimman abubuwan da suka faru kuma ta ba da ra'ayi kan yadda KMI Panel ake sa ran za ta yanke hukunci a kan kowane daya.

Manchester United 4-4 Aston Villa

Abubuwa biyu sun ja hankali a Old Trafford. Da farko, an ba Manchester United bugun fenariti bayan Boubacar Kamara ya yi foul a kan Matheus Cunha a minti na 16 — sake-sake sun tabbatar da farkon taɓawa ya kasance a ƙafar ɗan Braziliya, wanda ya mai da wannan yanke-shawara mai sauqi da kuma daidai.

Na biyu, kwallonkura ta Aston Villa a minti na 96, da Patrick Dorgu ya zura, ya zo bayan yuwuwar kura ta Senne Lammens a kan mai tsaron raga Zion Suzuki. La'akari da babban ƙofar shiga ta VAR a Premier League da ƙarancin taɓawa, ba za a iya cewa KMI Panel za ta ɗauka wannan kuskuren VAR ba.

Arsenal 1-0 Hull

Kuskuren da yake da yiwuwar faruwa mafi fili na karshen mako: Kai Havertz ya sami foul a ciki ɗakin bugun fansho daga Nobel Mendy, kuma jami'in VAR Michael Oliver ya aika alkalin Farai Hallam zuwa idon tafiya na gefen filin wasa. Duk da haka an ki ba da bugun fenariti a ƙarshe saboda an ɗauki Havertz yana cikin matsayin offside. Sai dai, tun da yake foul ya faru kafin kowane laifin offside, doka ta ce bugun fenariti ya kamata ya tsaya. Ana sa ran KMI Panel za ta rubuta wannan a matsayin kuskuren VAR.

Leeds 1-0 Tottenham

Omar Bogle ya kama Mathys Tel da abin da yawancin mutane suka ɗauka a matsayin kalubale mai haɗari, amma alkalin John Brooks ya ba da bugun 'yanci kawai. Jami'in VAR Tony Harrington bai aika Brooks zuwa idon tafiya don yiwuwar katin ja ba. Saboda Bogle ya yi taɓawa da kafafunsa na tallafi ba kafafunsa na ƙalubale ba, ra'ayoyi sun rarrabu tsakanin tsoffin ƙwararrun 'yan wasa — kuma hukuncin KMI Panel na iya dogara da tsarinsa wannan mako.

Everton 3-1 Coventry

Abubuwa uku daban-daban sun taso daga Goodison Park. James Tarkowski ya bayyana ya ja gashi na Caleb Yirenkyi na Coventry a ciki ɗakin bugun fansho — ba a ba da bugun fenariti ba, amma ana sa ran KMI Panel za ta yanke hukunci cewa ya kamata a ba da shi. Da'awar ta biyu ta bugun fenariti, don kalubalen Vitalii Mykolenko a kan Taiwo Awoniyi, ta bayyana an ƙi shi daidai, tun da taɓawa ta faru a waje da ɗakin kaɗan. Lamarin na uku — hannu na yiwuwa a cikin jerin abubuwan da suka haifar da kwallonkurar Thierno Barry ta minti na 61 ga Everton — na iya tsira daga hukunci saboda fasahar super-zoom da ake bukata don tabbatar da karkatawa ba ta samuwa nan take ba, yana kwaikwayon yanayi irin wannan da ya shafi Crystal Palace a kan Nottingham Forest a baya a wannan kakar wasa.

Brighton 2-0 Brentford

An kora Igor Thiago bayan bitar VAR don kama Chema Andres a kai da hannunsa na sama. Ko da yake niyyar ta bayyana ba ta nan, doka a fili take cewa taɓawa zuwa kai tana buƙatar katin ja sai dai idan ƙarfin ba shi da yawa. Shigar da VAR ta yi na iya tabbatarwa.

Crystal Palace 1-3 Liverpool

An ba Crystal Palace bugun fenariti a cikin dakikoki uku na karin lokaci don faulin Milos Kerkez a kan Dario Osorio. KMI Panel na iya ganin wannan a matsayin karo na 50-50 — yiwuwar kuskuren filin wasa maimakon wanda ya wuce ƙofar shiga ta VAR.

Sunderland 0-1 Chelsea

Cole Palmer ya faɗi a gefen ɗakin bugun fansho ƙarƙashin ƙalubalantar Luke O'Nien da Jules Ahoka, amma alkalin Jarred Gillett ya yi amfani da isyarar ci gaba da wasan. Saboda ana ƙayyade foul ta farkon taɓawa — kuma babu wata shaida mai ƙarfi da ke sanya farkon taɓawa a ciki ɗakin — ba za a iya sa ran kwamitin ya goyi bayan bugun fenariti ba.

Fulham 1-1 Newcastle

Newcastle United sun yi tunanin sun ɗauki jagora a Craven Cottage kafin a soke kwallonkurar saboda faulin Yoane Wissa a kan Timothy Castagne. Daraktan Matthias Jaissle ya bayyana takaicin sa bayan wasa, amma yanke-shawarar ta bayyana za ta iya tabbatarwa a matsayin daidai.

Shin da gaske ya kasance karshen mako mara kyau?

BBC Sport ta kiyasta cewa yanke-shawara biyu na iya ƙwarai a ɗaukar su a matsayin kurakurai na VAR ta KMI Panel: rashin ba da bugun fenariti ga Arsenal da Coventry. Ƙarin abubuwa biyu — kwallonkurar Barry da rashin katin ja ga Bogle — na iya kuma ɗaukarsu a matsayin kurakurai, ko da yake wannan zai dogara da tsarin kwamitin da ra'ayin su na subjective. Sauran abubuwan da suka faru a jerin sun bayyana an gudanar da su daidai. Wannan yana sanya yiwuwar jimlar tsakanin kurakurai biyu da huɗu — karshen mako mara kyau idan an yi la'akari da abin da ya kasance farkon kakar wasa mai tsabta ta musamman.