A catastrophic goalkeeping blunder from Lukas Hornicek handed Everton their first Premier League away victory since February, as a Newcastle United side reduced to ten men slumped to a fourth defeat in six top-flight matches.

The moment that decided the game

The key incident arrived when Hornicek failed to gather Tyrique George's tame effort, allowing the ball to squirm under his body and roll into the path of Thierno Barry, who could not miss. It was as straightforward a goal as Barry will ever score — though it extended a remarkable scoring run for the Everton forward.

The ten men of Newcastle then saw any hope of a comeback vanish when substitute Jacob Ramsey, brought on in the 75th minute to help rescue a point, was sent off instead — a moment that summed up the hosts' miserable afternoon.

Newcastle's struggles laid bare

From the outset, Newcastle looked disjointed. Right-back Amar Dedic managed a passing accuracy of just 59.1 percent in the opening 70 minutes, a telling statistic that reflected the home side's sloppiness in possession throughout.

William Osula had been a doubt heading into the fixture after twisting his ankle in the previous meeting between the two clubs. He started but managed only seven touches in the first half, offering little threat. Harvey Barnes threatened briefly — the former Leicester winger went close to marking his 100th Premier League appearance for Newcastle with his 100th career goal — but it was not to be.

Joelinton produced one inventive shot on the turn that appeared destined for the net before James Tarkowski intervened, while Anthony Elanga came agonisingly close when he kneed the ball against the post. Dan Burn, the Newcastle captain, was booked for a foul on Barry right on the edge of the area, though the resulting set-piece came to nothing.

Everton's disciplined masterclass

Manager David Moyes will have taken particular satisfaction from the performance of James Garner, who delivered exactly the kind of gritty, industrious display the new Everton boss prizes. Garner earned the match's standout rating and was central to the away side's organisation throughout.

Jarrad Branthwaite made a timely return to the starting eleven after missing two matches due to concussion protocols, while Vitalii Mykolenko was neat and effective at left-back. The result catapulted Everton up from 14th to 7th in the Premier League table.

Jordan Pickford endured predictable abuse from the St James' Park crowd but had the last laugh, keeping a clean sheet as Everton registered their fourth Premier League shutout of the season. Jake O'Brien and Tarkowski were commanding throughout, helping the Toffees to a third consecutive Premier League win at St James' Park.

Harrison Armstrong covered his face with his shirt after squandering a clear opportunity just before half-time, but Everton's defensive resolve ensured that near-miss proved irrelevant. Brennan Johnson and Michael Keane came off the bench in the closing stages to help see the win home.