Home/News/Premier League
Manchester City's Midfield Crisis: Can Maresca Fix the Fernandez Problem?
Premier League

Manchester City's Midfield Crisis: Can Maresca Fix the Fernandez Problem?

1 hour ago·3 min

Enzo Maresca finds himself navigating one of the most turbulent periods in Manchester City's recent history. After opening the season with seven consecutive wins across all competitions, City have since tumbled to three successive Premier League defeats — and the structural flaws that were always lurking have been fully exposed.

Too open, too easily overrun

Defensively, City are alarmingly vulnerable in transition. Only Newcastle have conceded more shots from fast breaks this season, and City shipped two goals from such situations in their defeat to Nottingham Forest before the international break — a game in which they conceded eight fast-break opportunities in total, more than any other side in a single match this campaign.

The root of the problem lies in midfield. Maresca's most-used double pivot of Elliot Anderson and Enzo Fernandez is a poor stylistic match when Rayan Cherki operates as the third central midfielder. Cherki contributes little defensively, which only works if both deeper midfielders press and tackle as a unit. At present, they do not.

Fernandez drifts into similar zones as Anderson — both gravitating toward the right side of City's midfield — leaving the system dangerously unbalanced. The Argentine tackles less and wins possession less frequently than he did at Chelsea, exposing the central third without compensating through his offensive output. At the City Ground, his defensive tally reached just four contributions, fewer than Cherki's five from the bench. Nottingham Forest's Xaver Schlager led all players with 14 defensive contributions; Ryan Yates added 11. Anderson, one of City's most dependable performers, was still caught out — directly at fault for Liam Delap's first goal.

A £320m headache

The financial stakes heighten the difficulty. City invested over £320 million rebuilding their midfield this summer, with both headline signings commanding fees above £100 million. So far, those two players' profiles have proved incompatible — and that is Maresca's problem to solve.

It is tempting to ask what Pep Guardiola would have done. His City sides always created numerical and positional overloads in midfield, with Bernardo Silva the master craftsman of that approach. In this context, some argue Bernardo's departure has hurt City's midfield balance even more than Rodri's absence.

The case for Bouaddi

If City need a ball-winner capable of operating under pressure at the base of midfield, Ayyoub Bouaddi presents the most logical solution. The teenager has featured for only 177 minutes in the Premier League this season and has had the international break to settle further. His physicality and positional discipline would ease the burden on Anderson and plug the gaps that sides like Sunderland, Nottingham Forest, and Ipswich have gleefully exploited.

Fernandez's alternative role

Dropping Fernandez entirely is not necessarily the answer. Maresca pushed hard to sign him just two-and-a-half months ago, and there is a compelling case for repositioning him at the tip of a midfield triangle rather than in a deeper role. He holds up the ball, draws fouls, attacks the box with good timing, and contributes in both creation and finishing. Yet to score from open play for City, he could still offer genuine value in a free role — provided adequate cover exists behind him.

Whether Cherki or Fernandez occupies that advanced position may ultimately depend on the game plan. What is not in doubt is that Maresca must prioritise structural solidity through his midfield spine above all else.

Fulham up next

City face Fulham this weekend. They have won their last 17 meetings with Fulham, scoring at least twice in every one. A year ago, Pep Guardiola's side conceded four goals at Craven Cottage and still prevailed 5-4 — but Maresca cannot rely on that kind of attacking firepower to paper over defensive fragility. Without a midfield fix, the chaos that has crept into this season risks becoming its defining characteristic.

Comments
Be the first to comment.
Related StoriesSee All