Questions are being raised about the Video Assistant Referee's handling of a penalty appeal involving Kai Havertz during Arsenal's match against Hull City, with analysts debating whether the correct call was made.

The incident, which took place during the Premier League fixture, has drawn significant attention from football pundits and supporters alike. Havertz appeared to go down inside the penalty area, prompting Arsenal to appeal for a spot kick — only for the decision to go against them after VAR review.

Ref Watch, the dedicated officiating analysis segment on Sky Sports, examined the incident in detail on Monday 9 November 2026, questioning whether the technology and the officials reached the right conclusion.

The debate highlights growing scrutiny around VAR decision-making in the Premier League, with supporters and commentators continuing to call for greater transparency in how the system operates and communicates its rulings to fans inside and outside the stadium.