Home/News/Premier League
Sunderland's Second-Season Struggles: Cause for Caution, Not Panic
Premier League

Sunderland's Second-Season Struggles: Cause for Caution, Not Panic

37 minutes ago·3 min

Second-season syndrome is one of football's most persistent clichés — a promoted side dazzles in its first year back among the elite, then stumbles badly the year after. Right now, Sunderland are living that reality.

The Black Cats surprised many last term, finishing seventh on their Premier League return — their best league position in 25 years — and earning European qualification for the first time since the 1970s. Yet expectations heading into this campaign were already tempered. Sunderland conducted relatively modest transfer business over the summer, constrained in part by heavy spending the previous window, and head coach Regis Le Bris himself acknowledged the strain of a congested fixture list. "We are exposed this season with this busy schedule. Is it unexpected? I don't think so," he said.

His words were delivered shortly before Sunderland beat Chelsea 1-0 for only their second Premier League win of the season. That result aside, the picture remains troubling: after 10 league games, they sit second-bottom of the table.

The numbers tell a different story

Yet beneath the surface, Sunderland's underlying statistics offer genuine encouragement. They rank seventh in the Premier League's expected points (xPTS) table — a metric derived from their expected goals (xG) for and against — which places them far from the relegation candidates their current standing implies.

Their core problem is clinical finishing, not structural weakness. With just eight league goals to their name — the fewest in the division — and three of those coming from Enzo Le Fee penalties, including the winner against Chelsea, Sunderland are simply not converting the chances they create. Statistically, they are the eighth-best chance creators in the top flight, with 15.6 xG accumulated so far.

Brian Brobbey demonstrated his threat in September's 5-3 defeat to Manchester City, scoring a hat-trick, but the striker has gone scoreless in all seven of his other Premier League appearances this term. A clinical centre-forward or two in January could transform Sunderland's season entirely.

Defensive concerns and the European question

Defensively, there is room for improvement. Sunderland rank 15th for expected goals against (xGA at 16.4) and have conceded 16 goals — almost exactly in line with that figure. It is not a catastrophic record, but tightening up at the back would only help their cause.

Their Europa League campaign adds further pressure. Halfway through the league phase, they sit 11th — just inside the play-off places — with trips to AC Milan and Anderlecht still ahead. Progress is far from guaranteed, and while European football represents a significant achievement for a club that spent eight years outside the top flight, including four seasons in the third tier, Sunderland's Premier League survival must take priority.

An early exit from Europe might, counterintuitively, be welcome — freeing up energy and resources for the league battle that really counts. Nottingham Forest offer a template of sorts: similarly creative but goal-shy earlier in the campaign, they appear to have flicked a switch by beating Manchester City 3-1 before the international break.

Second-season syndrome has led to relegation just 11 times in the Premier League's 34-year history, and only twice in the past 11 seasons — Huddersfield in 2019 and Sheffield United in 2021. Sunderland have the data, and arguably the squad, to avoid joining that list. What they need most urgently is goals — and January is not far away.

Comments
Be the first to comment.
Related StoriesSee All